Unanswered Prayers (Part II)

Every Wednesday night, my house fills back up.

DJ and Jake come home for dinner and now there is a Kate, too. For a few hours the volume returns to something resembling the old days, which, since it was in the last decade, isn’t all that old. Someone is digging through my refrigerator, everyone is talking at once, wine is being poured. There may be a discussion about who is doing the dishes and all I know is it darn sure isn’t me.

And then they leave.

The house gets quiet again, but it’s a different kind of quiet now. It’s the quiet after the dishes are done (not by me) and the boys I love most have gone home. I like it. I also can’t wait for the next Wednesday.

If you had asked me years ago to describe the life I wanted, I doubt I would have described this one. I had a more specific picture in mind. I was pretty good at making plans, setting goals, and getting things done. I had built a career that rewarded those qualities, and somewhere along the way I began to believe they should work just as well on the rest of my life, including the parts I couldn’t control.

I once wrote a Thanksgiving essay about the prayers God didn’t answer. I was writing it in the middle of raising two boys, when my evenings involved homework, college essays, video games, and the mysterious disappearance of gasoline from teenage cars. I thought I had a few good examples of those types of prayers. Now, I’ve got even better ones.

The first unanswered prayer I remember making was when I was thirteen and we were living next door to my grandparents. I came home from school and my mom told me that Grandma had died. I ran into the bathroom, locked the door, and cried into Grandma’s peach towels. I had never felt pain like that. I couldn’t imagine a world without the person I loved most, and I wanted the world put back the way it had been.

So I prayed. Take my mom, I told God. Just give Grandma back.

What a horrible thing to pray for, right? Hey, I was thirteen, devastated, and apparently under the impression that I could negotiate life. But the worst part is that I didn’t keep the bargain to myself. I lashed out and told my mom what I had asked for. She had every reason to be hurt. Instead, in the midst of her own grief, she understood that I was a child in unbearable pain. In a much later conversation, she told me that was the moment she realized just how my grandma’s death affected me.

I carried the guilt of those words for years. It took me well into adulthood to forgive that thirteen-year-old girl for saying something so awful. Ultimately, I understood that I wasn’t a terrible person. I was a heartbroken kid who wanted her grandma back and didn’t know what to do with the pain.

Not all my unanswered prayers were quite so dramatic.

In my early twenties, I was in love with a guy who was, at best, fond of me. I prayed that he would fall madly in love with me. At one point, he told me he did. Which, as it turned out, wasn’t quite the same thing as an answered prayer. He then slept with my best friend. That one didn’t require a whole lot of reflection. I was grateful God had ignored me almost immediately. And, if you’re wondering, after hours of crying and conversation, I kept the friend, to this day.

My thirties were a different story. By then, I had become accustomed to getting things done, and I approached my personal life with the same confidence I had in business. I wanted marriage and a family, and I wanted them on my schedule. I prayed for those things. A lot.

I didn’t think I was asking for anything unreasonable. I wanted a husband and children. I wanted the life I thought I was supposed to have, the one my grandma had, and I couldn’t understand why it wasn’t happening.

What I couldn’t see then was how I was treating a family like another goal to accomplish. I had a picture in my head of how my life should look, and I was so focused on when it should happen that I wasn’t giving any thought to what it would really mean.

David and I finally married. Then DJ came along. Then Jake.

I don’t know that I would have been ready for the life I wanted if it had arrived when I wanted it. The waiting I resented gave me time to become someone who could build a life with another person, rather than simply fit another person into the life I had already designed.

And then there was the other prayer I made more than once: I wanted four children before I turned forty. Yes, four. Hard to do when the first one comes at age thirty-six, but I’ve always been an overachiever.

I don’t know what version of myself thought that was a good idea. Two boys with different schedules, different interests, and a husband with his own ideas about how a household should run gave me plenty to manage. I can only imagine what four kids would have done to me. I suspect God was looking out for everyone involved when it didn’t happen.

The life I have now is not the one I would have prayed for then. It’s better in ways I couldn’t have understood at the time. Like what those Wednesday dinners would mean to me. Or how I would someday look forward to the sound of two grown sons arguing over something stupid in my kitchen. Or that the quiet after they leave would feel as much like a gift as the noise while they’re here.

I also couldn’t have known that the thing I once felt most guilty about praying for would become one of the prayers I was most grateful He ignored. I’m sure my grandma was tsk-tsking as she looked down on me.

I don’t think every disappointment is a blessing in disguise. Some things just hurt. But I’ve learned I’m not always the best judge of what my life needs, and I’m definitely not the one who should be in charge of the timing.

This Thanksgiving, I’ll be grateful for the people around my table, for the boys who still come home on Wednesdays, and for the life that showed up later than I wanted and two kids short of the plan. And I’ll also say a quiet thank-you for a few things that never happened.

Happy Thanksgiving! If you’ve got a prayer you’re glad went unanswered, tell me in the comments. I really do want to know.

Next
Next

Fuzzy Socks and Work Gloves